|
Indicator III-5
|
Undergraduate Humanities Majors and the Professions
|
|
NOTE TO READERS: Please include the following reference when citing data from this page:
"American Academy of Arts and Sciences, Humanities Indicators, http://HumanitiesIndicators.org".
|
In order to assess the extent to which individuals with undergraduate majors in
the humanities are prepared for professional employment, this indicator first focuses
on their performance on professional school entrance examinations in business, medicine,
and law. To be sure, data on the educational backgrounds of those taking professional
school admission examinations do not reveal what careers those individuals actually
pursue. Nonetheless, given the substantial fees and preparation involved in professional
school examinations, test-taking by humanities majors does in itself indicate what
career options they are seriously exploring. Moreover, test results can provide
some measure of the applicability of the humanistic knowledge and skills gained
in college to the entrance requirements for various professional occupations. After
reviewing such professional examination data, this indicator looks more generally
at professional degree holders in order to ascertain what proportion of them have
bachelor’s degrees in the humanities.
Data on who takes the
Graduate Management Admission Test
(GMAT), which are available from the Graduate Management Admission Council, reveal
that GMAT test takers are less likely to be humanities majors than graduates in
any other field, constituting 4–6% of all examinees over the 2000–2009 time period
(Figure III-5a). Students with humanities backgrounds have, however, performed
better than business majors, on average, and approximately as well as social and
natural science majors (Figure III-5b).
Like the GMAT, the
Medical College Admission Test
(MCAT) did not draw many of its examinees from the ranks of humanities majors, who
must do significant work in science, in addition to fulfilling the requirements
for their major, in order to be prepared for the MCAT and apply to medical school.
According to data provided by the American Association of
Medical Colleges, from 1991 to 2009 the proportion of those taking the MCAT who
were humanities majors was approximately 3–4% (Figure III-5c).1 Even though they were in the minority, humanities
majors were strong performers relative to majors in other fields. From 1991 to 2000
they were the highest-scoring group of majors on the MCAT, and from 2001 to 2009
only math and statistics majors scored appreciably higher (Figure III-5d).
Takers of the
Law School Admission Test
(LSAT) are much likelier than those of other professional school examinations to
have undergraduate degrees in the humanities. From 1996 to 2009, the humanities
share of LSAT examinees hovered around 20% of all test takers, according to data
provided to the HI by the Law School Admission Council (Figure III-5e). Over
this time period, humanities majors performed slightly better on the exam than behavioral
and social science graduates, and their average score was within one point of engineering,
math, and natural science majors (Figure III-5f).
From 1996 to 2008, according to data from the
U.S. Census Bureau’s Survey of Income
and Program Participation, approximately
6–8% of all noninstitutionalized U.S. civilians with medical degrees had undergraduate
degrees in the humanities (Figure III-5g). In 2008, 22% of those holding
advanced degrees in law (LL.B., J.D., and Ph.D.) had majored in humanities (down
from the 2001 high of 28%). This proportion was larger than that for any other field,
and it would have been even greater if those with bachelor’s degrees in history—a
discipline considered by the HI to be part of the humanities field, but one that
the Census Bureau classifies as a social science—had been included (Figure III-5h).
Note
1
The figure excludes the percentage of examinees who reported an undergraduate major
in biology. These students are the majority of MCAT test takers.
The AAMC defines the humanities field rather differently than the HI. The former
considers library science and the performing arts to be humanities disciplines but
treats history as a social science discipline.
|